Monday, May 21, 2007

Taking the fight against hospital acquired MRSA into your own hands

Think of it as a ‘Do it Yourself’ kit for preventing hospital acquired infections (HAI). The kit is a collection of disinfecting wipes, hand rubs and other products designed to prevent patients from catching a bug while they’re in the hospital.

The “PatientPak’ is marketed in the UK for about $43. The web site for the product is long on promises short on specifics (www.patientpak.com). Consider this text from the company’s press release:

The PatientPak Hand Sanitiser and Sanitising Wipes are the only products available that are tested and proven to kill and clean away MRSA and at least 99.999% of all bacteria, including dangerous viruses, Norovirus and Bird Flu. Combining a cleaning detergent and bacteria-killing disinfectant in one, harmful bacteria are killed in just 10 seconds. PatientPak’s Hand Sanitiser and Sanitising Wipes, the most extensively tested products on the market, are also the only MRSA-killing products that are hand safe with just 5% alcohol, meaning that food can be eaten after application with no need to re-wash hands.”

Maybe I’m reading this wrong, but the first sentence indicates that viruses are a subset of bacteria (see bold text). A quick scan of the web site reveals no corroborating case studies or published data on germicidal efficacy. If the products are indeed the most, “…extensively tested…” shouldn’t the test results be available?

I’d like to know how the sellers know that the products ‘kill’ bird flu? Was it tested against H5N1, or was it a surrogate? Or does it work against Influenza A, and therefore it is assumed to likely be effective against bird flu?

I’m also sceptical of the germicidal effects of a detergent that is used for 10 seconds. To the best of my knowledge, detergents do not ‘kill’ or deactivate microorganisms. Detergents help water remove and dilute contaminants. It is generally accepted that washing your hands with a detergent (soap) requires a good 20 seconds or so. I may be wrong, but since the company does not provide an explanation of their technology or other scientific studies, we are forced to use the information that we have.

On the positive side, I like the idea of empowering people to actively participate in their healthcare. Bringing the PatientPak to the hospital is not necessarily a sign that a hospital is not doing its job. To me it is an indication that HAIs are environmental issues requiring a broad-based strategy. While hospitals need to do more, I wouldn’t bet my life on it.

So, would I buy the PatientPak? No, not based upon what I know of the kit so far. I do not believe, however, that it will cause any harm. It might actually help. There’s a lot of sizzle in this product promotion, but not much science. It is always wise to remember that there are no panaceas for HAI.

4 comments:

Rhoda said...

I agree with some who say that the creators of The Patient Pack are trying to cash in on current MRSA panic but as you say it could be better than nothing! I myself wouldn't buy it either as I have my own arsenol of tested products including the new Body Armor, an alcohol free germicidal lotion that continues to kill germs for four hours fter applied.

sales said...

Thank you for your detailed report regarding Patientpak
You are quit right regarding the lack of dater sheets on our web site at the moment,That will be rectified shortly, however if you had sent me an email I would have been very happy to send all the dater that you required allowing you to make a more informed report please goto www.gamahealthcare.com/science.html to read and verify our clams.

If You require any more information pleas do not hesitate to contact me.

PatientPak is on a sales promotion at the moment @ £15.99 including VAT

Kind Regards
H.J.McEvaddy
Managing Director
PatientPak Ltd
UK

James Sanders said...

Hi,

On further research the products the hand sanitiser and the wipes are manufactured by GAMA Healthcare, and there website http://www.gamahealthcare.com/science

contains all the data to prove the claims. Have to say it is pretty impressive.

I just bought a pack for my cousin who is in hospital.

kalvinfrnk said...

I have my own arsenol of tested products including the new Body Armor, an alcohol free germicidal lotion that continues to kill germs for four hours fter applied.
hospital disinfectant wipes